对中国系统论宪法学的反思

陈运生

对中国系统论宪法学的反思

Reflections on the Systematic Theory of Constitutional Law in China


    期刊名称:《法学研究》
    期刊年份:
    作者:陈运生
    单位:
    中文关键词:系统论宪法学;社会系统理论;规范宪法学;社会宪法
    英文关键词:the systematic theory of constitutional law; social systems theory; normative constitutional law; social constitution
    中文摘要:
    系统论宪法学研究以社会功能分析作为逻辑起点,在研究立场上偏向于经验主义,在方法论上贯彻“从存在推导出当为”的基本论证模式。其认为社会生活的各种经验是宪法实践的规范基础,因而试图通过客观描述系统现象及系统现象得以形成的事实要素,对宪法实践作出妥适的解释与说明。然而,建立在全社会功能分化基础上的系统概念,并不能使特定的宪法实践脱离一般宪法准则。并且,由于对宪法实践的描述经常需要运用价值判断,存在与当为之间又无法进行逻辑推导,系统论宪法学的学术主张虽有一定的现实解释力,但在理论深层仍有反思空间。
    英文摘要:
    The systematic theory of constitutional law takes the differentiation of social functions as the logical premise, leans towards empiricism in research standpoint, and implements the basic model of “deduction from ‘is’ to ‘ought’” in methodology. This theory takes various experiences of social life as the normative basis of constitutional practice and attempts to provide appropriate interpretation and explanation of constitutional practice by objectively describing the systematic phenomena and all the elements that form the systematic phenomena. However, the concept of a system based on the functional differentiation of the whole society cannot separate specific constitutional practice from general constitutional norms. Moreover, since the description of constitutional practice often requires the use of value judgment, and there is no logical derivation between “is” and “ought”, the academic proposition of systematic constitutional law, although has certain practical explanatory power, still needs reflections on the deep theoretical level.
    全文阅读:  点击下载

相关文章!
  • 中国数据跨境调取路径探析——以

    特定情况下的数据跨境调取需要在传统的司法互助协定方式基础上补充其他路径。中国在坚持以双边司法互助协定和互惠原则为主要方式的基

  • 折中主义与理想主义之辩——评西

    美国西蒙尼德斯教授在新著的《全球冲突法立法:国际比较研究》一书中,提出晚近国际私法背离了萨维尼理论所追求的理想主义,呈现折中主义

  • 离岸信托避税规制的域外经验及

    作为信托的类型之一,离岸信托是指根据外国法律设立的信托。在信托本身固有的灵活机制之上,离岸信托充分利用了离岸管辖区的税收优势,成